Saturday, February 26, 2011

Coins issued by Ovinius Tertullus at Nicopolis ad Istrum: I, Earliest

AN ESSAY ON THE DIES OF COINS SIGNED BY TERTULLUS AT NICOPOLIS AD ISTRUM
I. The earliest Tertullus issues

Frontispiece.  For its place, see below.
Preface
Wishing to present these coins discursively rather than in any tabular form, concentrating on the portraits and reverse types, and to keep the digital files as simple as possible, I am relegating to the end a catalogue list, with documentation and accurate recording of the legends on the specimens used here, together with their weights and measures.  Such presentation also permits considerations and questions where conclusions would be premature.
Beginning with Auspex, and continuing with Gentianus, the obverse dies used with signed reverses at the Nicopolis mint are much more artistically pretentious than those of Marcianopolis, comparable rather in this respect with those of Philippopolis, a richer, larger, older city.  The third of the governors of Moesia Inferior as such (the governors of all Thrace signed coins  of Antonine Nicopolis) was Ovinius Tertullus, for whom we have much data but little real knowledge apart from the coins.  Though Gentianus’s primary portrait die for Nicopolis is very fine, Tertullus used only the Nicopolis mint and was the first to issue signed tetrassaria for Julia Domna; it also fell to him in AD 198 to celebrate Caracalla as Augustus and his brother Geta as Caesar.1

The primary Septimius obverse dies of Auspex and Gentianus with an early Tertullus

The Septimius portrait most closely related to those following Auspex and Gentianus
The image of the Haimos range as a rustic youth in kothornoi (but not the theatrical kind) to protect his shins, with a hunting spear, no more than a bit of drapery across his lap, in rocky terrain, with at least a bear beside him (Aurelius Gallus will give him a leaping deer as well) was not newly created, or newly adapted to coinage, at this time; Gentianus had issued one already for Septimius.
The Gentianus Haimos (photo courtesy ctr)

I am confident that Pick was right: this reverse die, if not original with the die engraver (but it is more pictorial than Pella’s), derives from a painting at Nicopolis.  Pick knew only Julia Domna’s signed by Tertullus; we now have that of Septimius to go with it.  Hereafter, through Elagabalus, Haimos reverses seem to be obligatory for every ruler for whom the Nicopolis mint was used.  It is surprising, perhaps, that Caracalla has none, so far.  The gesture that Sir Kenneth Clark intuitively called ‘passive’ and the crossed legs are body language that we are not confident in reading, but Haimos and Pella have convinced me that they are non-urbane, postures that perhaps would not pass in Theophrastus’s Athens.  Tertullus’s engraver, indeed, adds the apron and uncrosses the legs.  Note, too, the peculiarity (not unique here, however) of writing ep’ istrô rather than pros istron.  Here we may note that, particularly in the brow and nose, the unique Tertullus die for Domna is very probably by the same engraver as this one of Septimius.2
The Tertullus Haimos

Whereas Pick had only Domna’s Haimos, he had only Septimius’s Nike Driving a Quadriga.
For this issue, too, we now have both.  The portrait dies are the same (for Domna, of course, there is only one), but the termination of the ethnic in pros istron shows that the alternative of epi followed by the dative is just that.
Septimius and Domna with Nike in Quadriga

While a Tertullus coin for Domna, however, must always have this one refined and winning obverse die, and its pairing with the Gentianus-like portrait of Septimius (note also the small and careful letter forms in the legends) shows that it is early in Tertullus’s tenure, its pairing with different portrait styles for Septimius leaves the latter in need of other comparanda, even with a reverse giving  us another epi ethnic.
Domna and Septimius with Iconic Hera

With her back mantle spread out flat, with the stiff profile of her head and body, with scepter, veiled head, and patera, this curious image almost certainly is intended as Hera, but as an archaic cult image of Hera (though not so age-old as some venerable xoanon).  The legend of the reverse die—not only its preposition but its small, neatly space letters—resembles that of the Haimos reverse with which we began.
The portrait of Septimius, with a fold of his military cloak wrapped close to his neck and pinned, with his round head and vigorous expression, recalled some of the portraits used in Thrace with reverse dies signed by Statilius Barbarus, such as this one (perhaps representing Thrakia in her own landscape) of Philippopolis:
Sta. Barbarus issue for Septimius at Philippopolis

Certainly the Barbarus portraits are not identical to the Tertullus ones, but their more naturally wavy laurel ties (not as if lifted by wind or electrified) and the heavier forms of the head are more than accidentally similar, and the larger and rather emphatically mannered letter forms also are comparable with some on Tertullus coins at Nicopolis.3

More with ep’ Istrô ethnics
Before attempting to determine more closely the relationship between the tenure in office of Barbarus in Thrace and Tertullus in Moesia Inferior, we may consider the coin shown as a Frontispiece to this web page and the best preserved Tertullus Domna known to me.  Both have Tyche as a reverse, and Domna’s is Pick’s no. 1451 (Varbanov 2005, no. 2093) but it is Septimius’s Tyche that is genuinely statuesque, and it is his coin that has the most perfectly punctuated legends.  His portrait die is evidently that of the Haimos and Quadriga, above, but only the Tyche preserves both the obverse and the reverse legends completely, each slightly more conscientious than usual: AVT•KAI•L•SEPTI•  |  SEVÊROS•PER•  (a point even after the abbreviation of Pertinax) and VPA•OOVINI•TERTULL | OV•NIKOPOLI•EP•ISTRÔ (only the ‘legs’ of the omega survive, but, even when small and cramped, the points are all present).  When a Provincial coin is so well struck and so well preserved, it is tempting not to look beyond the fine portrait and the relaxed contrapposto and convincing drapery of the Tyche.  Domna’s Tyche is not quite its equal,4 but they do look like coins issued as a pair, and both use epi.  By the way, the Domna portrait seems to anticipate in all the pairs so far considered the convention of a smaller scale for the empress’s head and bust, a principle most thoroughly applied in the mosaics of their retinues for Justinian and Theodora in the choir of S. Vitale at Ravenna.  Also, the Septimius bust, in particular, helps us to make sense of the conventions used in the bust with drapery over armor, as seen from behind, on the coins of Macrinus only two decades later.  Some accident, however, has altered the expression of the eye on the Septimius portrait.
Other Tyche reverses signed by Tertullus do not occur with this Domna die and are rather different.  Here Domna’s Tyche is merely more commonplace in style.
Septimius and Domna with corresponding Tyche reverse dies

Another Domna, not known by Pick, exists in a ‘ghost’, barely VG so far as condition goes but sufficient for description.  Unlike the Tyche, which was practically unpublished as Pick 1451, the Hermes coin is not in Varbanov, Engl. edition.  For the Hermes with a Rooster (much finer than the one for Septimius and Caracalla), VPA OOVIN and EP ISTRÔ (in the exergue), together with Domna’s portrait die, guarantee the identification.  The graceful anatomy of the Hermes, also, is sufficiently preserved to distinguish it from later ones.  The design of the reverse is related to that of the Tyche.
The Tertullus Domna with a Hermes and Rooster

In this preliminary essay, I would also call attention to a River coin in another collection that has the same obverse die as the 'statuesque Tyche', the Haimos, and the Nike with Quadriga:
The River God reverse at left, by association with the obverse die most closely related to that of
Gentianus, will be the first of Tertullus's River reverses.

The Eagle with Folded Wings, regardant, holding wreath to left (Pick 1452)
The damage to Domna’s eagle, where an area of the design is lost, may have been to the die, since the shape of the eagle is shown on the Gentianus coin.  The Domna shown here preserves the reverse legend that Pick and Tacchella had to work out between them; as on the last, it has OOVINI, not just OOV; the Septimius and Domna reverse are the same die, but the Septimius portrait is not one of the above and seems to be a worn die, while this eagle reverse (not in Pick or Varbanov for Septimius) has been listed only for Domna.  The sharp and straight edge of the wing on these emphasizes the eagle’s power in flight.
 
Eagle Regardant: Pick 1452 for Julia, Septimius (rev. die match), Pick 1270 for Septimius, and Gentianus's as their antetype


All of the preceding seem certainly earlier than the first coins for Caracalla at Nicopolis ad Istrum as Augustus.

1. The evidence for the dating of the first three governors (apart from perhaps his brother) of Moesia Inferior can be found in Arthur Stein, Die Legaten von Moesien, Budapest, 1940, pp. 84–85, with citation of their primary publications and commentary, and, transcribed in full, in some cases with further citations in Dilyana Boteva, Lower Moesia and Thrace in the Roman Imperial System (A.D. 193–217/8), Sofia, 1997.  I follow Stein’s more cautious approach to dating, though for Tertullus the monumental inscriptions (the earliest from the summer of AD 198 and the last from AD 201; we have an inscription naming Gallus in AD 202) are quite secure.  We have more primary chronology for him than for any other governor.  For Auspex we only have the single date AD 195, and for Gentianus, for all the elegance of the coins he issued, we only can be certain that he followed Auspex and necessarily must be placed before Tertullus. 
2. Doubtless some smaller coins, especially the 3 assaria of brass, the module usually specific to empresses and Caesars, such as her Aphrodite, have a portrait extremely similar to the sole large die with reverses signed by Tertullus, and the 3 assaria for Caracalla are die-linked to it.  These (a) show Caracalla still as Caesar but not so childish as on the earliest looking coppers, and (b) should be datable either to the term in office of Gentianus or to the beginning of Tertullus’s term, before July of 198.  In a final essay in this series, I shall try to align the small coins with the larger, signed ones.
3. Boteva, op. cit., pp. 332, in fact, aligns Barbarus with Gentianus or “197/8”.  But making the terms in Thrace and Moesia Inferior always begin and end simultaneously seems a little rigid, especially for a governor who, like Gentianus, not only shared pre-existing Auspex dies but also is so apparently continuous with Tertullus and has so few dies of his own, though of the highest quality.  After all, a man might sicken or quarrel or whatever, and be suddenly out of office.  In any case, the resemblance of some Barbarus obverses, not this one alone, is more than accidentally similar to some issued by Tertullus.
4. Domna's Tyche is of the principal variety on coins of Moesia Inferior.  For the statuesque Tyche on this one of Septimius we might compare Tychai at Tomis, but this one, while just as particular, seems likely to have had a unique prototype, of artistic rather than iconographical significance.

Saturday, February 12, 2011

The "Ares Borghese" and Philippopolis

The "Ares Borghese" in the Louvre (June 2002)
Statues of Ares (unlike the Roman ones of Mars) are rare.  This type is, indeed, the only one of the last third of the 5th century: that is, it is a copy, and we have only the briefest literary allusions to the type in Athens.  Pausanias saw an Ares by Alkamenes in the sanctuary of Ares in the Athenian Agora alongside an Aphrodite by a different sculptor.  Alkamenes was Pheidias's Athenian disciple, Agorakritos being Parian.  The sanctuary that Pausanias noted, and its temple, had been transported from Acharnes and carefully reconstructed there in the time of Augustus; the masons' marks for reassembling it correctly were studied when the Agora was excavated.  That fact would help to explain why this type of Ares has a helmet that is Roman, though the style of the statue is that of a very good early Imperial marble copy of a 5th-century Athenian statue.  There would be nothing remarkable in updating the god's helmet if an Athenian copyist's atelier needed to make a new one.  And the distinctive stance and bodily expression of the Ares are extremely like the "Dresden Zeus" (whether the latter be Zeus or Hades), so, I think, it is quite certain that both copy 5th-century originals by the same artist, very likely Alkamenes.
(the Dresden statue from an old photo badly scanned but my own)
We have other copies of both of these statue types, so there is no doubt that in the Empire period they were known and admired.  Presumably both were bronze, but remember that Ares' helmet and shield  and the Zeus-Hades' scepter (the Dresden statue's forearms are restored) could have been of other materials.  There is no possibility, I think, that either or both of them were classicizing, imitative creations of the early Roman Empire.  Both have, by the way, more than one 'good' view:
(Consider, too, that the Dresden statues were in a basement gallery)
A cast-gallery photo shows how radically different a late Polykleitan stance and these actually are:
Bonn, Akad. Kunstmuseum cast collection; the Attic statue does not use the "walking pose"
Finally, let us notice that ankle band which so exercised scholars of the 19th and early 20th centuries; they took it as a mark of enslavement and wanted to prove which enslavement it pertained to.  Accustomed to macho bangles of all sorts, I have never regarded it as anything else, and it is not as if we had other statuary types of Ares to compare it with.  At least one of the die engravers at Philippopolis in Thrace, in any case, rendered it very carefully, leaving no doubt (as if the pose left much) that it is this Ares type that is shown from Hadrian to Elagabalus on their bronze coins.
There is no possibility of proofs here, but we may summarize that the "Ares Borghese" may be an Augustan version of the Greek war god who, nude and hardly armed, was quite different from Roman Mars, including the equally Augustan Mars Ultor, who is understood to have worn "anatomical" armor.  This Ares, perhaps (if the association in the Agora temple is relevant), was particularly aptly paired with Aphrodite.  It is in Antonine Rome in the reign of Marcus Aurelius that we have wealthy, very possibly funerary, portraits of a man and wife as Ares and Aphrodite (for she is of the "Aphrodite from Capua" type, the prototype for the "Aphrodite from Melos").  Showing not only rulers but others who could afford for funerary use statuary in the guise of deities, Hermes (like the one from Andros) for instance, was not new, and orators and poetesses also (like the younger Herculänerin) also served.  Ptolemaic queens had paved the way for empresses as Aphrodite (though now Hera-Juno was the proper mate for Zeus-Jupiter).  So man and wife as Ares and Aphrodite, Ares' customary mate, was new but not extraordinary in Imperial Antonine society.  Diana Kleiner in Roman Sculpture, p. 280, says, "We know from Cassius Dio (81.31) that Marcus Aurelius and Faustina the Younger were celebrated as Mars and Venus"—but the citation to Dio Cassius must be wrong, because there is no Book 81, and Book 80 is late Severan, and Book 71, which would be the right date, exists only in the epitome, which abjures such tittle-tattle.  However, one must agree that these very datable statue pairs allude to the empress and her husband, though made for perhaps their friends.  Three pairs exist, but the third, from Ostia,  is plainly Commodan.
The Louvre pair, at left, is a little later than the Capitoline pair, at right
The "Aphrodite from Capua", of course, is only half draped and quite bare-breasted, but just as the so-called "Hera  Borghese" could have been Juno when used for the body type of an empress (Livia for example) and given thin drapery to cover her shoulders and breast, but was really an Aphrodite type of c. 410 BC, so the type known to us first from Capua usually wears a thin chiton when as a Roman domina she is paired with Mars as her husband (but not on the Commodan pair from Ostia).
I do not know of this couple on a coin, but the large statuary pairs illustrate how fashionable it was in the Antonine period, and that is when, or rather with Hadrian, the "Borghese Ares" type also belongs to Philippopolis.
Philippopolis, coin of Domitian with Ares-Mars reverse
In Flavian Philippopolis, the god of war is a regular Roman bearded Mars with "anatomical" armor over a tunic almost to his knees and his right hand resting on a Roman shield.  At other Danubian mints, as for example at Nicopolis ad Istrum or Marcianopolis for Macrinus, this Roman Mars will persist, reminding us that Greece had normally no cult of her Ares: as always, myth and cult are not the same thing.
Therefore, it is impossible to decide whether, beginning with Hadrian, Philippopolis had acquired a copy of her own of the opus nobile that we know as the "Ares Borghese" as a civic agalma or to replace a Roman Mars as a statue for the Imperial cult or, least likely perhaps, for the naos of a cult of Ares as a Greek god.  Whichever it was, Philippopolis was proud of it; its governor was pleased to put it on coins for successive emperors.
Philippopolis.  Small coin of Hadrian with "Ares Borghese" seen from proper left
This vantage point is the usual one on the coins (no palm trunk support, of course)
On this specimen of Hadrian's Ares, the shield on his left forearm is not very clear, owing to corrosion.
The Ares coins known to me for Antoninus Pius at Philippopolis are still small.
Philippopolis.  Two reverse dies of Ares for Antoninus Pius
Only the small bronzes with Dionysos reverses are commoner than the Ares
Both of these dies show the only kind of variation that we see in this series, placing the shield (though a Greek shield) on the ground and a spear in his left hand and one of them the stock patera in his right.  We recall, first, that in the statuary portraits the Ares may be given the spear, too, and second that this is the kind of casual placement of detachable attributes that we see both in the realm of copies and on coins (such as those of the Apollo Sauroktonos at Nicopolis) that represent them.  Remember, too, how from one generation to the next, freestanding statuary in churches may experience such changes, the addition of a gold crown of thorns, for example, or the placement on the ground of a heavy attribute until such time as it can be adequately re-attached.
Philippopolis.  Small bronze of Septimius Severus with Ares Borghese reverse
The portrait of Septimius looks rather early in his reign, certainly earlier than the pompous portraits on large bronzes here datable after AD 205 (when Philippopolis was given the title Metropolis).  This time the die engraver not only restores the shield to Ares' left forearm, where the Greek shield permits his holding a spear as well, but shows the body in front view and wearing a baldric (as on the Ostia portrait pair).
1980s photo of the "Ares Borghese" in what we regard as a front view
As in other representations on coins, inappropriate foreshortening, as of the shield with its edge facing the viewer, is avoided, but it has been noticed repeatedly that the foot plinth of this statue also implies its installation favoring the face nearly in side view and the face of the shield (decorated?) quite visible.  The Bonn cast stripped of restorations is useful:
Bonn, Akad. Kunstmuseum.  One of a group of teaching photos from the 1980s
Probably a decade or so later, we have the most detailed rendering, on a large die, of the Ares Borghese at Philippopolis:
Philippopolis.  Large bronze coins, in matching style and letter forms, celebrating both brothers as Augusti, laureate, Caracalla with the Ares and Geta with Nemesis (fully equipped), c. AD 209
Caracalla's Ares, though technically elegant, is, like other figure types commonly from late Severan onward, insensitive to the three-dimensional composition of the statue, especially noteworthy since it seems likely that Philippopolis actually owned one.  In other words, the old Alois Riegl observations, in his Spätrömische Kunstindustrie, that bodily three-dimensionality and the sense of a background as representing light and air in space that three-dimensional things inhabit, are increasingly denied or ignored, are by and large borne out by thousands and thousands of surviving coins.  There are many exceptions, the work presumably of older engravers or of engravers trained in workshops deep-dyed in tradition, and hints of this change can be picked out much earlier, given our hindsight, but not far into the 3rd century of our era the feeling of gingerbread men lying on a cookie sheet comes to prevail.  It is not a falling off of quality; the Caracalla and Geta are beautiful coins (as are, for that matter, the nice, big folles of the Tetrarchy and not a few Constantinian coins).  It is a radical change, as if a cultural genome had evolved to the point of producing a new species of art and of thought, I daresay.
The Caracalla Ares, notwithstanding, is the one that guarantees the identity of the type as an Ares Borghese: that ankle band!  Even for persons disposed to argue that anyone could do a figure in this pose (the sort of thing that doesn't happen, however), there is that ankle band, unique, not something that anyone would have done without a prototype.  It even shows how the Greek shield band permits Ares' holding a spear as well.
Caracalla's is not quite the last Ares Borghese at Philippopolis, though the production for Elagabalus is much smaller and it is the last from the Philippopolis mint.
Philippopolis.  Large bronze for Elagabalus, with reverse showing Concord of another nude male with the Ares Borghese statue-type.
Again, though likewise only a large bronze coin, not a medallion, no larger than a sestertius would be, this is not an ordinary issue, since it boasts a neokoria, a civic distinction rarer in the Danubian cities than in Asia Minor.  Here, certainly, the Ares is not merely the representation of a nice statue that Philippopolis had; it can stand in for her, as the Apollo Lykeios might do for Marcianopolis.  That being so, we must ask the identification of the nude warrior in 3/4 back view, helmeted with a chlamys over his left forearm and holding a spear in his left hand.  A baldric across his back suggests a parazonium suspended on it.  The naming of these handshaking figures in catalogue listings will reveal the difficulty of naming both figures on most of them, and unless the young emperor can be nude in this context, I do not know in this case.
Finally, it is possible that accidents of preservation preclude seeing the ankle band on more of the foregoing.  Finding so many as I have located has been difficult enough without fussing about perfection.
Proper full identifications for the coins are provided in the Picasa album.
Here is a short list of references for use with the statues:







For the Ares, see Evelyn Harrison's article "A Classical Maiden from the Athenian Agora" in Hesperia: Supplement XX (Studies in Athenian Architecture Sculpture and Topography) 1982, pp. 40-53, pls. 4-8 for a whole education on dating--as usual, the article contains much more than the title promises.  This is where I first became interested in the comparison of the Ares Borghese with the Dresden Zeus or Hades, which is real, no matter how you identify and attribute the originals of the statue types.



J. J. Pollitt. The Art of Ancient Greece: Sources and Documents, rev. ed., Cambridge UP, 1990.  For sources cited, in translation.

John Boardman, Greek Sculpture: The Classical Period, 1985, pl. 223.  For further notes, p. 247, beginning near end of first column.

Claude Rolley, La Sculpture grecque, vol. II, 1999, pp. 148-149, for the Ares; his notes, more extensive and up to date than Boardman’s, are in the margin of each page.

Diana E. E. Kleiner, Roman Sculpture, Yale UP, 1992, pp. 280–283, for the Antonine portrait pairs.

Luigi Todisco, Scultura greca del IV secolo, Milan, 1993, pl. 12, for a really good photo of the Dresden statue.

Ivan Varbanov, Greek Imperial Coins, III, English edition, Bourgas, Bulgaria, 2007.  So long as we have no real monograph for Philippopolis, this is the best we have for Philippopolis, the online provisional edidtion for the Antonine volume of Roman Provincial Coins at the Ashmolean Museum itself being limited for the time being.


Saturday, October 30, 2010

Aristodikos in Opera Nobilia


You can zoom by clicking on an image.  Those not included here are in the Picasa album of this name.
Neither of these Attic grave-marker statues is colossal, as the earliest kouroi from Samos (and for that matter the Attic one from Sounion) are, but both are significantly over life size, and both are masterpieces.  Until Aristodikos (found in 1947) was published, Kroisos, the kouros from Anavysos in Attica, claimed the place of honor in this gallery in the National Archaeological Museum, in the center with a background of his own, in the position occupied by the bronze god from Cape Artemision in the next large gallery.  Kroisos had stood on a traditional three-step base, and we have (found near by) its middle step, asking the viewer to stop and behold Kroisos who, slain by furious Ares, died in battle.  He certainly was named after Croesus (to use the Latinized spelling), the famous Lydian king, and we'd love to know why.  Both the lettering and the style of the kouros support a dating about 530 or in the 520s BCE.  Counting at least three generations to a century, and seeing that the comparanda for Aristodikos are a generation later (there is no space here for rehearsing them all), this, the last great kouros, is datable about 500 BCE.  In this case on the top step, into which his foot-plinth fits, his name still is written ARISTODIKO for the genitive case, because the O is for the false diphthong.  
The stance of the kouros, adopted from Egyptian statuary, together doubtless with the techniques of quarrying and working large stone, and immediately adapted for Greek use (made freestanding in the round and fully nude) once Egypt was opened by the middle of the 26th dynasty, may at first have been partly an exigency.  Merely to make a couple of tons of hard stone, monolithic, stand on two thin legs, only with one advanced to assist, perhaps, in balance, was daring enough, and there were no examples in east Africa, the eastern Mediterranean, or western Asia Minor of monumental, substantive, nude statuary shown moving, turning or shifting weight (let alone in a monolith), to help or challenge the Early Archaic Greek sculptors of ca. 600 BCE.  Even Egyptian statues in wood (or bronze, maybe), which could stand alone, stood in the same stance with one foot forward (and so with legs of slightly unequal length).
The kouros is almost always either votive, in a sanctuary, or funerary, as a grave-marker.  A few votive kouroi bear inscriptions, right on the statue, dedicating it to the relevant god, but naming the deceased youth is rarer: the inscription perhaps was regularly on the stepped base as it is for Kroisos and Aristodikos, and such blocks usually were recycled for building, being ready-made for ashlar or for steps and sills.  The pose was not inappropriate for a young god, such as Apollo, but the Archaic date of even the big kouros from Piraeus, as well as its name as Apollo, is contested and has been since it was found in 1959, and other pretty Apollos in kouros pose are surely late Hellenistic, neo-Archaic.
As European Classical music did with Sonata Form, so did Greek art with generic types that were full of possibilities.  Like the Walking Pose and the Leaning Pose in Classical and Late Classical Greek sculpture, so the Kouros in Archaic and Late Archaic was worked with till, as such, it could yield no more that was new.  Aristodikos, it is fair to say, has all the understanding of the human body that is needed to cease being a kouros type; indeed, not needing to support themselves on their own legs, the marble pedimental giants, Peisistratid and only a bit later than Kroisos, are undeterred by the difficulties of doing something (at the scale of the Classical Parthenon itself) that had never been attempted before.
Perhaps it was not only the challenges (the twisting torso, the clavicles embracing the neck to the trapezius, the muscular flesh folding at the knee, not to mention composing a gigantomachy in a pediment) but the dignity of the serene youth in death that the kouros by now expressed that made the pose last as long as it did.
Here are Aristodikos, in strict front view, the Kritian Boy from the Acropolis, and the odd little kouros from Agrigento.  The Wiki uses a picture of the Agrigento kouros to illustrate the Hellenistic, technical limitation of the word ephebe, but it is the Acropolis boy that is a mere adolescent.  Aristodikos is a young man old enough to have died perhaps still ephebos yet perhaps like Kroisos old enough for military service.  But the Kritian boy, which in all probability (see Jeffrey Hurwitt), really does date from the very last years before the Persian sack of the Acropolis and thus is only about 15 years later than Aristodikos, is no longer a kouros (since we use that word, though in early Greek it just meant 'boy', for a particular stance and type): his weight is on his left leg, so that his spine must curve a little, his pelvis tilt, his free right leg bend its knee (and if complete allow him to use his right foot just to balance), and to complement that movement his head turns a little to proper right.  This statue is not life size, though over 3/4, so the weight of the solid torso on the slender legs is not quite so serious as with the large grave-marker statues.  The Agrigento boy is smaller, but it seems to be just Western conservatism that made them choose a strict kouros stance, with all the muscles and proportions, facial expression and hair style, of the Early Classical period to which it belongs, chronologically (logically, of course, work is dated by its latest relevant traits, and this one is well past c. 480, though the pelvis, considered as a complex of bones in the body, is not well understood).  Aristodikos has a pelvis capable both of cradling his innards and socketing his femur bones, but for the moment it is not in action.  It is this real pelvis that permits the sculptor to give the thighs proper proportions.  Kroisos from Anavysos has thighs like those on the Siphnian Treasury at Delphi, which cannot be later than c. 525 BCE.
It is not rules of thumb, such as trivial details that patrons might wish to retain on a funerary or votive sculpture, that are relevant to dating it, relatively, in a series.
One of the korai from the Acropolis, dated usually in the first decade of the new century, that seems very comparable with Aristodikos, has ripple-wave hair and stylized zigzags on the edge of her diagonally draped himation, just as he has snail-curl patterns for the curls around his brow, but these decorative details might also be chosen even later than these two works.  What is alike is the powerful skulls and mandilbles and level brows, as well as the relative size and placement of their facial features.  It was a tragedy that Aristodikos was 'discovered' by a plough.  His features must have survived almost intact until that moment.  Enough remains, though, to make this comparison.  He and Kore #684 belong in that tradition favoring heroic massiveness—as distinct from sheer bulk as from daintiness—among several studio traditions represented among the Attic Archaic marble sculptures.  Kroisos from Anavysos belongs to it, too.
Like Kroisos, too, not that they are intimately related, sylistically, Aristodikos is really appreciated best in  3/4 views, whether from the front or the back.  The treatment of the crown of his head, by the way, may show that while alive his hair was flattened by his helmet (Kroisos actually seems to wear a knit cap to prevent the helmet from abrading and, in effect, shearing his hair).  In any case, his somatic type is no longer that of a soft adolescent—and gangling boys, like Michelangelo's David, are really rare in Greece; the famously tall  Evzone guards come mostly from the northern parts.
Finally, what I never discussed in lectures at my university.  Everyone knows, of course, that Greece glorified male beauty.  In the Introduction, pp. 1-25, of  Classical Greece and the Birth of Western Art, Cambridge UP, 2008, Andrew Stewart provides the best statement I have seen in a lifetime of reading on the subject of Greek nudity.  It is well and good, confronted with a class of kindergartners, to explain that antiquity had none of the knits and synthetic fibers that gym clothes are made of today, and, Greece being as warm as Louisiana, they did their physical education in the buff, but I never dared confront older children, let along undergraduates, with a line like that.
Let us return to the initial statement, above, that Greece immediately got rid of the Egyptians' little skirt, though it is incomparably easier to sculpt a human body without having to deal with the pelvic girdle, that fulcrum of our living bodies.  It was for dedications to deities as well as for representations of young deities and, above all, for the representation of the human person as he should be for the afterlife, for eternity (put it as you will: as the gods made him, perhaps) that Greek ethos thought nudity important.  It is a more pervasive and profound idea than that, as in the Truth of Apelles, nudity 'symbolizes' Truth.  Greek art, especially in its youth, does not deal in Symbols.  

In the case of Aristodikos, however, we have something more explicit.  Even if his face had not been damaged it was no more exactly and sensitively represented than his genitals.  Later Greek art, Hellenistic genre art and erotic art, like the Barberini Faun, or ethnically descriptive, like the Dying Gaul, show weathered and much-used genitals.  Those, however, are descriptive of essentially verbal ideas about those subjects.  On Aristodikos we see the parts that Paul of Tarsus called shame, parts that Victorians, irrespective of what they did with them, did not name at all, parts that even on my newborn infant brother I was not allowed to refer to (but the grown ups made cute little jokes about)—we see them rendered as tenderly as a sleeping baby's face, showing inner structures and the way the skin encloses them.  Twice I have mentioned this fact to someone else, someone of my own generation, and twice was sorry to have embarrassed one and shocked the other.  But in fact the rendering of every part of Aristodikos with equal (and, be it said, unique) reverence is precisely what is not shameful, not even erotic, in this statue.  It is, after all, the publicly exhibited grave marker of a very wealthy, very aristocratic (I dare say) landowner's son, tragically dead when barely grown and shown exactly as his family would wish him remembered, him whom they had named Aristodikos.
Most of the erotic, occasionally downright, deliberately pornographic pictures on Greece vases are on drinking equipment and, besides, were shipped off to the Etruscans.
A professor might, with some reservations, repeat something a bit risqué to a class, but not try to teach them something that probably they will not understand.  One does not want to be asked whether 'that' will be on the test, or not.
May I recommend again Sir John Boardman's Greek Sculpture: The Archaic Period (World of Art) and the above-mentioned book by Andrew Stewart.

Wednesday, October 20, 2010

Concerning those cathedrals


The Early Gothic 4-part elevation and 6-partite vaults
of Notre Dame de Paris

Speaking of those Cathedrals

Last week in this my second blog, Opera Nobilia, I mentioned the reference to Biblical numbers in the design of the great Gothic cathedrals of Europe.  One might recall, too, the importance of perfectly measured predetermined relationships in the design of Buddha statues and paintings, like the perfect circle, too, of Mary’s head in Christian icons.  As the Classical Greeks had studied nature, and not least the human body, to discover what was ideal (and, reading Vitruvius, the Renaissance in Leonardo’s Vitruvian man and in Palladian proportions followed them), the classics of the 13th century looked rather to the Bible for perfect numbers (not that it is at all clear that its authors chose them for proportions).  It was Abbot Suger, who had been reading the 6th-century Syrian pseudo-Dionysios for his mysticism of light, who reinterpreted that and numerology in creating the Gothic style, but it was the builders, the engineers and the ilk of Villard de Honnecourt, who realized Suger’s ideas: made the cathedrals stand and made them lovely.  In the century when poets in springtime first looked at real flowers again (instead of working from antique floweriness), Amiens has all the way around its interior a lovely, natural garland of flowers, not just motifs.  When sculptors had, quite obviously, been looking at the drapery of Greco-Roman statuary, we see again cloth that hangs softly and enhances a body implied within it.  And (shame on NOVA), when builders had for a couple of generations been aware of double-centered arches in the mosques of southern Spain—and don’t forget the crusades—they took up the challenge and created Gothic vaulting.  The foregoing merely attempts to draw attention to some of the best studies of the 20th century, by alluding to them; it is no substitute for reading the works themselves.  One mid-century study, wordy as it is, contributed a key concept: Du Miracle grec au miracle Chrétien, by Wm. Deonna, though it is not so famous as the works of Wittkower, Panofsky, E. R. Curtius, Katzenellenbogen, et al.  It is the 13th century in Europe that rediscovered and revered the way things really look, and based figural arts on close observation of living things, leaving only further development to the Renaissance.  Almost all other art had relied very much on schemata.  Working from primary experience of reality to make art was the miracle.  It isn’t at all just copying.  I mean, pace NOVA, the Biblical numerology that we see in Medieval art is not the most important thing about it; it may even be just a sop for Cerberus, for the churchmen and some of the devout.  It isn’t what makes the cathedrals great, least of all graceful, harmonious Amiens.  NOVA might better have considered the engineering of the cathedrals in more detail and left to others what it seems not to understand fully.

Tuesday, October 12, 2010

"The measure of all things"

Olympia Metope, Apples of the Hesperides  (yes, a generation earlier, but radical in its own right)
author's snapshot in museum
I was reminded by another viewing of the NOVA program on the Parthenon of the basis, gradually built from all my experience of ancient Greece and all of the modern writers that I most admire, of my convictions concerning it: the founding of Greek art and thought in the keenest and most devoted empirical study, in particular of the human body and mind.  It searches for, and finds, the universal and mathematical in the particular and the concrete.  I revere this.
I have no time now to try to write an essay, and, besides, I cannot compete with the best studies that exist, so I shall post simply this statement.
In the TV blurb announcing next how the great cathedrals were built (and I love them, too), the announcer says that they looked for divine numbers in the Bible.  The difference, not to judge but to notice, between endeavoring to make buildings and figural representations to adhere to a divine text, and endeavoring to find what inheres in everything and then making art and architecture accordingly, and thus separate philosophy from worship (while still loving the ancestral deities), is the radical division that runs through all our civilization.  Call it Protagoras vs Plotinus, if you wish, though that is much too crude a reduction.

Friday, September 17, 2010

Bronze Statuary 3 (Appendix)

This is the draft of March 2007 that I abandoned. The notes, converted to endnotes by saving it as html, are useful if anyone wants their more complete and accurate references. What would have been notes to the catalogue of coins is incorporated in the Forvm Ayiyoryitika article (for the list and picture references, see the main Post, Bronze Statuary 3, which as exposition readers who have read several versions find clearest. But it does assume the contents of the Posts Bronze Statuary 1 and 2. As I can, I'll come back and make the list numbers bold. Whether I can link to the endnotes, I don't know (at least, I don't know how). Possibly, hardly anyone will want the extra information here, but I'll post it anyhow.

The Coins of Apollo Sauroktonos
 
 Overlooking the uniqueness of the succession of Apollo Sauroktonos representations on Danubian bronze coins has prevented their receiving the specific kind of attention that they require.  Older art historians repeatedly analyzed and compared the corpus of freestanding copies of the Praxitelean statuary type, often arguing that one or another was validated by the two coins that Overbeck and Pick had used to illustrate it.[1]  They may have left the impression that the subject had been exhausted, when numismatically it hardly had been touched, and, besides, coins that Pick barely knew and others that were unknown to his generation are now available.  The availability of all the obverse types, with the reverse types, now enables a real study of the Sauroktonos coins.[2] Unifying the methodologies of kindred disciplines  no longer is disconcerting; in this case, classical archaeology simply is reintegrated, but not to address old questions in old ways.  First, therefore, we must revise the questions affecting statuary types and their use, especially in the 2nd and 3rd centuries AC, on Greek Imperial coins.[3]
                  The reverse types in Greek Imperial coinage include a great variety of statuary types.  Venerable cult images such as represent their cities on alliance coinage were either actually or purportedly extremely ancient, and we guess that their origin was in the Early Archaic 7th century.  They were badges of the antiquity and sanctity of cities and cults.[4]  Ancient texts regard them as admirable but do not assess them as works of art.  The evidence of the coins of Ephesos and Alexandria, Troas,[5] for instance, shows that the sanctuaries also were graced by statues that appealed to later taste, statues that probably were of bronze and stood in the groves of the sanctuaries.  There were statues, also, among the elder Pliny's opera nobilia,[6] that had become more famous, more axia idein for tourists, than the cults themselves, such as the Aprhodite of Cnidus or the Eros of Thespiae or the Eros of Parium.[7]  Certainly the languorous statue of Apollo in the Athens Lyceum was more famous than the shrine of the earlier imported cult of Apollo Lykeios, which gave its name to the near-by school.[8]  The statuary compositions of some of these were widely recycled.  There were, of course, also the many statues that Pausanias noted as he visited their sites, too often (for our use) mentioned only generically: a statue of Pan, for example.
                  The Apollo Sauroktonos by Praxiteles, though one of the best attested of all Classical statuary types, not merely cited but actually described by Pliny, stands apart from any of these.[9]  The incident it depicts is not in traditional mythology, though it may allude playfully to Python; Apollo had no boyhood narrative apart from the descriptions of this statue.  Much as the boyhood of John the Baptist created in the Early Renaissance was unattested in Biblical scripture and theologically unimportant, so the idyllic young Apollo was created by Praxiteles for connoisseurs.  If it stood in a sanctuary or temple (as the famous Hermes at Olympia, being marble with some tinting, stood in the Old Temple), it was as a dedication, not for cult.  We do not know (and Pliny may not have known) for whom it was made, or where, or even whether the original survived in the Antonine and Severan periods when the Sauroktonos coins were issued. Though almost certainly created in bronze, it is in Pliny's book on stone,[10] and the familiar copies from Italy are of marble. It may have been on the basis of a smaller, bronze version, however, like the Villa Albani statuette, that Martial encapsulated the Lizard-Slayer in his epigram.  Two copies in Athens also are of marble.  We now understand that pointed copies were made from plaster casts out of reassembled piece molds, the latter taken either from the original or from an intermediate copy.  Indirect hollow casting of bronzes also could utilize piece molds. Noticeable differences in alignment and thickness occurred, and the finishing always was by hand, by eye, varying as the workshop had, or lacked, firsthand access to the original.  Accessories, such as tree trunks and lizards, might seldom have utilized piece molds.  Variations inherent in these processes do not compromise the identity of the type.[11]
                  The frivolity of the Sauroktonos statue is delusory; as a realization of a leaning pose, the stance is at once stable and precarious; as a study of adolescent nudity, it is miraculously free of pornographic allure.  Even in copies, its artistic consequence justifies its fame, though we cannot guess how those who issued the coins saw it.  It shows the august deity absorbed in a boyish sport, playing darts with a lizard, apparently aware of nothing else, his own godhead included.  His hairstyle and nudity, of course, signify his identity to us.  The action transforms the leaning pose, because his right hand held a dart aimed at a lizard on which his attention is fixed, and the tree trunk is essential to the anecdote, not a superfluous support.  Leaning poses abound in Classical sculpture; for the Sauroktonos each element is essential.  The Vatican copy preserves the right hand.  A head in the Benaki Museum in Athens, no. 23722, unretouched, preserves his boyishness.  The root marks remaining on the Athens torso, National Archaeological Museum no. 1623, guarantee the modeling of a subtle copy, easily destroyed by cleaning and polishing.  Its plumpness agrees better with the Louvre than with the Vatican copy, but they may merely reflect slightly different copyist traditions.  It is remarkable indeed that some of the coins captured the essence of the pose, seen either frontally or somewhat to the statue's right side, but not surprising that others simplify and clarify its composition.  The essential thing is that it is indubitably a Sauroktonos.
                  Here we must emphasize that the use of this leaning pose does not per se make a Sauroktonos.  Wonderful poses were freely used when new statues were wanted, and not only under the Empire.  Pastiches were not despised or regarded as plagiarism.  So any ancient person would admire the Apollo of Apollonia ad Rhyndacum as an admirably contrived offshoot, not later than Hellenistic, and not as a Sauroktonos, since it pointedly replaced the tree with a column and had neither a lizard nor a dart.  The ancients liked to talk about the attributes of images, and it is hard to doubt that at Apollonia ad Rhyndacum their Apollo was regarded as distinctly their own.[12]  Borrowing the graceful posture simply made good sense, but, significantly, Apollonia ad Rhyndacum stripped this one of its anecdotal, fundamentally secular attributes.  On other coins, too, we see famous poses evidently recycled, as when a young athlete becomes a young god.[13]
                  Although, from the time of Perikles and Pheidias through the period of Alexander of Macedon (the date of Pliny’s enigmatic deinde cessavit ars),[14] urban Greeks made celebrities of their most successful artists, urban Romans scarcely acknowledged their own sculptors and metalworkers.  They hired others to adorn their lives, just as the wives of Chicago meatpackers a century ago went to Paris for the clothes they would wear to attend an opera season imported from Europe.  What one buys is often simply appropriated as paid for, and so we know nothing of the artisans, some of them excellent artists, who created special dies for coins.  Nor do we know who chose the figure-types in their repertory, or if the engravers might offer suggestions.  Of course, for the recently founded Trajanic towns in Thrace and Moesia Inferior, exceptional types needed someone’s official sanction, particularly when these recurred over three quarters of a century and did not correspond to the city’s regular types.  Therefore, it is necessary to say even before discussing it that the almost exclusive occurrence of Apollo Sauroktonos on the coins of Nicopolis ad Istrum cannot be explained.  It seems generally to have been chosen for young Caesars, but apart from Nicopolis only at Antonine Philippopolis and nowhere else.  The sole exception, a single issue at Prusa ad Olympum in Bithynia, has for its obverse a laureate and bearded Commodus.  The Sauroktonos never appeared on a coin or medal of the Rome mint.
                  On Greek Imperials of the 2nd and 3rd centuries we see some statuary types that originated as freestanding works existing in their own right adopted, evidently, as cult statues in temples; for example, the Athenian Apollo Lykeios type appears in tetrastyle temples on coins of Marcianopolis, where, fundamentally frontal and self-contained, it looks perfectlyappropriate.[15]  Statues in strong leaning poses, compositions that also needed to be seen from more than one vantage point, seem inappropriate and, in fact, the Sauroktonos never is shown in a temple.  Apollonia ad Rhyndacum, in fact, shows its statue only as seen from the door.  As an anecdotal subject to delight connoisseurs, a real Sauroktonos seems particularly unlikely as a cult statue.  Besides, Nicopolis regularly used the conservative standing Apollo, with laurel twig and patera, as its deity type.[16]  Pick may have been right, however, that Nicopolis actually had a Sauroktonos statue,[17] and perhaps Philippopolis had one, too, and Prusa.  If so, and they stood in civic gardens, they may well have been bronze rather than marble copies.[18]  Given the re-usability of sets of piece molds and the possibility of making new bronzes by off-casting from pre-existing copies, it is important to realize that, even had the original been inaccessible or destroyed, a new city might have its own.  As witness to good copies on the Danube frontier, in fact, the early excavations at Nicopolis itself produced a very nice adolescent Eros, related to the Parium type.[19]
                  The processes by which copies were made, much better understood since the publication of the Baiae workshop, have a large literature of their own; here, because it is with the type that the coins are concerned, it will suffice to refer to the marble copies in the Louvre and the Vatican.
 
The Antonine Sauroktonoi (1–9)[20]
                  The only Apollo Sauroktonos reverses not from Nicopolis ad Istrum are Antonine.  Three of the nine are from Philippopolis and visibly closely related to those from Nicopolis; the fourth is the only non-Danubian and visibly quite independent.  The first ones, 1–4, were issued under Antoninus Pius when Marcus Aurelius was a young Caesar; they are much alike, though one of them, 4, is from Philippopolis.  Portraits of Antoninus Pius are almost ageless, but, as Pick pointed out, the governor’s name, Zeno, dates 1 (AMNG I, 1, no. 1225),  ca. 143[21].  We now have closely similar anonymous issues, unknown to Pick, nos. 2 and 3, die-linking Antoninus Pius with his new, young Caesar, and 4, so closely related that, even without his name, they look like a joint issue by Zeno.  These four are true to the statuary type and slightly stiff, in keeping with the prevailing decorum of Antoninus Pius’s coinage.  Each has a lizard on the tree trunk where the statues show it and the right hand poised to hold a dart; the figure is foreshortened rather than unfolded (Pl.  , fig.  ).
                  Antoninus Pius’s larger Sauroktonos at Philippopolis, 5, is weaker in style but normal (except that his legs are miscrossed), and it was issued by the last Thracian governor of his reign, Gargilius Antiquus.  At Perinthos, where this governor is named, Marcus Aurelius is bearded.  The other previously published Philippopolis coin, 6, issued for Faustina II perhaps by Marcus Aurelius, since she wears her hair at the occipital level, is known in several excellent specimens.  It is not properly a Sauroktonos, lacking not only the lizard but also its tree, yet it is unlikely to have been engraved independently of the Sauroktonos types.  It is the first to show the boy’s right arm not foreshortened but folded back, semaphore-like.  He does hold a dart, though he rests his outstretched left arm on a column or stele, at the base of which is, perhaps, a quiver (clearer on one reverse die than on the other).  The type being unique, we can only guess that the little boy at once alludes to a child Commodus and to his father’s Sauroktonos coins as Caesar.  Certainly the engraver consulted neither a copy of the  statue nor a nice gem nor a Sauroktonos coin in legible condition.  Except in the context of Sauroktonos coins faithful to the statuary type, no one could call this one by its name.  No further Sauroktonos coins are known from Philippopolis.
                  Represented by a cast at the Ashmolean Museum, we do have a normal Sauroktonos for Commodus at Nicopolis, 7; this seems to be a rough copy of his father’s.  For Commodus laureate and bearded, we have several good specimens of a small copper at Nicopolis,  8.  Both the tree and the Apollo are rigid and spindly, but it seems to be a tree, not a column, and it has a lizard, though the lizard is at the level of his legs and might be unidentifiable without its little feet.  Both of these were unknown to Pick, who did remark that some of Commodus’s dies are exceptionally bad; this die-pair certainly would distressPraxiteles.  In one particular it anticipates the ambiguity of M. Agrippa’s Sauroktonos for Macrinus, 20, a full generation later: what is the right hand doing?
                  The graceful Sauroktonos at Prusa ad Olympum, 9, unique and overlooked by Lacroix,[22] also has a laureate Commodus obverse.  The lizard and the dart are only implied, but the posture and the tree are unmistakable, and the die gives one the sense of a real statue—a bronze statue requiring no gratuitous transverse branches from the tree trunk as struts.
The Sauroktonoi of Septimius and his family
                  Septimius’s first governor of Moesia Inferior as his consular legate was Pollenius Auspex,[23] and a group of anonymous coins, quite large (up to D. 28mm), mostly unpublished, must be described here to justify the conclusion that the first Sauroktonos for Septimius was issued before the installation of Cosconius Gentianus.   First, we have a Capitoline Aphrodite (what the 19th century called “Venus Pudica”, but that term is more generic) with Auspex’s name, C1, its obverse die being that of AMNG I, 1, nos. 1254, 1255, 1257.*  We also have the same Aphrodite type, but anonymous,  twice, C2, C3, once from very fresh dies but cruelly double-struck, and its obverse die at first glance might be mistaken for the listed Auspex die.  The obverse die used with the signed reverses, however, is very neat and round-browed and much more suggestive of three-dimensionality.  The anonymous coins are linearly expressive but flat and structurally loose in comparison.  This latter obverse portrait, probably the same die, is that of  10.  Several specimens, well preserved but unpublished, all have the same die pair.  Almost identical, but a different die, is an anonymous river god, C4, not identical to the listings at AMNG I, 1, nos. 1258-1260, with reverses  signed by Auspex.  This anonymous river god has the ill-jointed arms and over-size head of a Commodus river god (ibid., no. 1235, Taf. XVII, 31, which should be rotated about 45° clockwise), and it is not impossible that the atelier that made some of Commodus’s dies remained to work on Septimius’s first ones, cutting second-string dies.  The Sauroktonos, however, is slender and charming; though the large head might be a folk-art trait, as on the river god, here it makes the Apollo childlike.  The lizard, or snake, is at the level of his thighs, but in his right hand he holds a laurel twig with small leaves, as if intending not to transfix the lizard but swat it.  This is a Sauroktonos but an aberrant one,  as 8 was.
                  At early Severan Nicopolis, 11 first gives us a Moesian governor’s name; the small coppers for Septimius and Geta, 12 and 13, have none, but one of the reverse dies, 13, used for both Septimius and Geta, should not antedate 198, when Caracalla was named Augustus and Geta raised to Caesar.  Probably all three date from about that time.  Some, but not all, of the obverse portraits of Septimius used with them are quite early looking.
                  The coins issued in the name of Ovinius Tertullus initiate a new phase in Nicopolitan coinage.  For him a lovely, young Julia Domna obverse was created and the finest of all the Septimius obverses, as well as the legend-in-wreath acclamation on coins for Septimius and his sons, and 11, Caracalla’s first Sauroktonos, AMNG I, 1, no. 1518.  An excellent engraver created its engaging Caracalla portrait, recalling but improving on some of the Eastern Mint denarius dies.  The Sauroktonos on the reverse, as young as the prince, still a plump child, indeed resembling Caracalla, leans forward like the Louvre copy of the Sauroktonos, is amused by an open-mouthed lizard—and prepares to swat at it with a laurel twig in his right hand, which is drawn back but lowered.  What is this?  There is no hint of naiveté in this die.  Septimius had already had his elder boy represented as an infant Herakles about to throttle the menacing snakes; the statue is in the Museo Capitolino.  Could he (or his agents) have ordered for Nicopolis a variant Apollo Lizard Slayer, with laurel to make him more patently Apollonian (though less a Sauroktonos)?  Even the first Antonine Sauroktonoi, which are canonical, require an available prototype.  If a Sauroktonos had been dedicated for Marcus Aurelius when Antoninus Pius made him Caesar, another for Septimius’s son might be all the likelier.  Such an inference compounds speculations, but the use of this statuary type for coinage here was most exceptional, and the pretension of Antonine lineage seems to have been important to Septimius and, surely, well known to his appointed governors.
                  Whatever the actual excuse for it, the Tertullus Sauroktonos reverse is a deliberate variant of the canonical type.  It will recur, deliberately.
                  With the Tertullus Caracalla portrait, and its characteristic letter forms, we may compare the least well known, 12a, of the small, copper Sauroktonos coins that Pick’s no. 1354 may subsume (the description and legend match, but the Berlin specimen, 12b, is a pair of peculiar dies that, at best, qualify as an incompetent variant).  On 12a the small Apollo stands straight but, unlike that of Commodus, 8, is sturdy and muscular, anatomically credible.  His dart is emphatic, with a large arrowhead.  The stance is unlike the statues, but it might have been taken from intaglio gems like those in the British Museum that Rizzo and Picard illustrate.  The supporting leg and the thorax are frontal, permitting the arms to be spread as if to throw a javelin.  Surely, 12b, perhaps the only one Pick knew firsthand, is only a secondary die.*  12c, on the other hand, though stylistically distinct from  12b, is careful and competent work. 
                  Because the Rousse die, 12a, is closely related, both in the style of Apollo’s anatomy and in the letterforms of the ethnic, to the Tertullus die of Pick’s 1518, 11, very likely it, too, was issued c. 198.  Caracalla’s unpublished tetrassarion with ΕΥΤΥΧΩΣ ΤΟΙΣ ΚΥΡΙΟΙΣ in a wreath, C5, lacks the circumferential legend naming Tertullus, but it shares the obverse die of 11, so both the acclamation and the die place it, too, c. 198.
                   The shared die, Pick’s 1355 for Septimius, 13a, and 1639 for Geta, 13b, also probably celebrates Geta’s elevation to Caesar and if so is contemporary with these.  It was used eventually even with a serious die break (see pl. 00).  The head of Geta seems always to be the same, a portrait as fine as Caracalla’s on his larger coin.  The incorrect obverse legend, giving ΑΥΡ as his nomen, is early; as Pick says, his name is already corrected on nos. 1622-1624, issued by Tertullus for both brothers.  Geta’s die, however, is a true Sauroktonos.  This die, capturing the action, both tense and easy, of the boy Apollo leaning forward in a position to strike the lizard, is closest to the stance of the Louvre’s marble copy.  Caracalla, in fact, had nothing like it.
                  The next group of Sauroktonos reverses, issued by Aurelius Gallus, were, possibly with one exception, 14, part of the numerous and varied issues relative to Caracalla’s marriage to Plautilla in 202.  The die that stands apart is Septimius’s, Pick no. 1288, the art-history textbook coin for the statuary type.  It is rarely seen well struck but it was a masterly die by any standards.  The figure of Apollo is elegant and convincing in its foreshortening and anatomy; the obverse die that seems always to accompany it is a classic early-Gallus portrait die.  The reverse, as statuary in its effect as Antoninus Pius’s, 1 and 2, conveys far greater alertness.  But the remaining Gallus Sauroktonos dies, beginning with the shared die, Pick 1289 for Septimius and 1539 for Caracalla, 15a–b, are comparatively graceless.  The Apollo figure lacks the tectonic and organic integration of parts that impart a sense of life, as in masterly Classical sculpture.  The portrait of Caracalla, now about 14 years old, is one of a set of draped busts and heads (the nicest used with the Nicopolitan Propago Imperi reverse), all in similar style and probably all close in date, c. 202.  Caracalla himself has a second pair of dies for the Sauroktonoos, not listed separately by Pick, 15c.  What is most remarkable is that Plautilla (Pick 1626), 16a, and Geta (Pick 1654), 16b, both have Sauroktonos tetrassarion reverses, too, issued by Gallus.  Indeed, they share a reverse die, with a slenderer and more graceful Apollo, his arms spread very wide, so that the composition really is unfolded or flattened.  Young empresses otherwise do not have Sauroktonos reverse dies.  Even Julia Domna has no Sauroktonos.  Plautilla, furthermore, whether to honor her or her father, also has a Capitoline Aphrodite reverse, though only Domna has Aphrodite with Eros.  Geta’s portrait die, which recurs with a fine Dionysos reverse, Pick no. 1656, is extremely fine.
                  A century ago, we had only a belated postscript to the foregoing, in two Sauroktonoi issued for Macrinus, who did, after all, emphasize his feigned blood ties to Septimius and re-named his own son Antoninus.  Then, in 1989, a dealer’s illustrated list offered a tetrassarion of Septimius, issued by Fl. Ulpianus, the last governor or Moesia Inferior to issue coins in his lifetime, with an unmistakable Sauroktonos reverse, 17a.  The head of Septimius on the obverse die was unlike the toothless old emperor of most late issues, the legend even ended in Π, and the Sauroktonos was plainly a quotation from the Tertullus issue of c. 198, 11, with a laurel branch instead of a dart in Apollo’s lowered right hand.  Neither laurel twig nor lizard has distinctive characteristics, but both are present, and the knobby upright is surely a tree trunk.  Though this coin, known only from the photograph, may be unique, the reverse type, with its own die, was also used for Caracalla, 17b.  By this time, Caracalla was into his twenties and bearded, but the portrait (now in scale armor) is of a beardless youth.  His features are rather generic, though others of the unaccountable beardless Caracallas of Ulpianus, which Pick remarked on, seem designed to resemble the child of Tertullus’s engraver, 11.  Around the Sauroktonos, even the tipsy Υs and Λs and the broad Πs characteristic of many Tertullus legends seem to be imitated.  With his father not yet dead, and himself still young, such a retrospective issue certainly shows that the Apollo Sauroktonos with a laurel twig was not an ignorant accident.  It even tempts one to think of Caracalla (if only we knew how much he was aware of what was struck here in his name) as sentimental about his shining boyhood.  Besides, we have not seen the last of the laurel-twig variant.
                  Statius Longinus, the first of Macrinus’s governors of Moesia Inferior, whose obverse portrait dies for Macrinus may be aligned with his first issue of denarii in Rome, issued a remarkable Sauroktonos die for Macrinus, 18.  The figure of Apollo is lithe and alert, balanced leaning forward, on the verge of releasing the dart in his right hand (here held at a convincing angle).  The lizard is nearly worn away, but its presence does not seem in doubt.  To see the statue in this configuration, one must move around it, to the right (Pl.  , fig.  ).  In this respect, it resembles the Prusa Sauroktonos of Commodus, 9, rather than its own Moesian predecessors.  In either case, the engraver seems to have known Sauroktonos statues and understood the formal motif of the composition, but a generation later this one is more remarkable.  This die pair is exemplary of the best of Macrinus’s remarkable coinage at Nicopolis and Marcianopolis, the two mints chosen, evidently, to produce bronze coins for the entire region.  It was not known to Pick, but two others for Macrinus are in his lists.
                  P. Fu. Pontianus, who succeeded Longinus, used the Marcianopolis mint, except for a few coins.  Two of his Nicopolis obverse dies continued to be used by the last governor, M. Cl. Agrippa.  One of those, 19, with a reverse die still signed by Pontianus, is a  Sauroktonos, Pick’s AMNG I, 1, no. 1679 (a single specimen in Vienna).  It is later than 18, which, in my opinion, used one of the earliest Longinus obverse dies.  Within a fourteen-month reign, of course, it cannot be much later.  The reverse is not in good condition, but a new photograph seems to confirm Pick’s customarily careful description, distinguishing an “Apollo in the posture of the Sauroktonos” (no. 1518, here 11) and a depiction of the actual statuary type, even when some details have become unclear.  At no. 1679, he marks ‘dart’ and ‘lizard’ with a question mark but calls the type “Sauroktonos” and specifies, “den r. Arm zurückgezogen”.  His help is welcome: the stance, therefore, resembles that of the Longinus reverse.  This is noteworthy, because the remaining two Sauroktonoi are quite different.
                  The Agrippa Sauroktonos for Macrinus, 20, Pick’s no. 1687, used since Overbeck to illustrate the Sauroktonos from coinage, in fact is problematic as such.  The obverse portrait is still related to that shared with Pontianus and even more closely to one used by Longinus, but it is much scrawnier.  Even the best preserved reverses, with intact patina, of this fairly common coin give no hint of what Apollo’s right hand was doing (if he had one), where it ought to be rendered in front of the torso, but I know several that plainly show a dart held in the left hand at the extremity of the tree trunk, a tree trunk executed by four offset gouges.  Between the torso and this tree trunk, against the field of the coin, joining the torso and perhaps also the tree trunk, is a slightly wavy gouge, which, on the best specimens, is flanked by two pairs of pellets (they do not join up).  A lizard?  A leafy twig (if so, not clearly laurel)?  With the right hand absent and the dart (in the left hand) out of play, the interpretation of this thing as a lizard requires an act of faith.  It recalls, however,  8 for Commodus, which has on at least two specimens the same combination: an indefinite right hand and an indefinite object, not clearly a lizard and possibly a twig, between the torso and the tree.  After the Longinus and Pontianus Sauroktonoi, this detailed but aberrant  representation is astonishing.  At Nicopolis, 8 and 20 must be part of the Sauroktonos series, but neither of them seems to be an intelligent and deliberate variant, and Agrippa’sMacrinus Sauroktonos, like his “Medici Aphrodite”, ought never to be reproduced, Overbeck notwithstanding, as a straightforward representation of the type.
                  Agrippa’s issue for Diadumenian, 21, on the other hand, is an accurate rendition of the variant with a laurel twig in the lowered right hand.  It is a fairly faithful copy of the Ulpianus die, 17,  the Sauroktonos for the  beardless Caracalla that seems to be retrospective.  This coin is still rare, if indeed the specimen shown here is not unique, but it is important that it does exist.  Diadumenian had his own Apollo Sauroktonos, linked to an obverse die in the mannered style that may mark Agrippa’s final issues, its engraving being also somewhat coarse.  The Sauroktonos is again the variant, 11, created for Caracalla when he was made named Augustus jointly with his father, a fact that may have been recalled in using it for Diadumenian.  Further speculation is indefensible, but this surely is a deliberate and meaningful variant of the Apollo Sauroktonos type.
                  Though by now we could not be surprised if a Longinus Sauroktonos with an obverse for Diadumenian were one day published from still unstudied regional collections, Pick must be right that there were none for Maesa’s grandsons and none later.  The relatively extravagant cultural pretensions of c. 198–218 were abandoned in Moesia Inferior.  Elagabalus’s coinage, issued by Novius Rufus, is quite different and has different pretensions.
Tentative conclusions
                  It must have become obvious that in studying these coins I came to think that, at least at Nicopolis and at least in the Severan period, changing consular governors are associated with changing styles and choices of types and standards in the production of the bronze coins of Moesia Inferior.  Also,  the Apollo Sauroktonos was used to celebrate the young heirs to the imperial throne and was chosen because it was an opus nobile celebrating divine adolescence (at least by playfulallusion).  Further, it seems to me to be part of the Antonine pretensions of Septimius and so of Macrinus; since Antoninus Pius and the young Marcus Aurelius had these new and unique reverse types, so should Septimius and Caracalla (and, as Caesar, Geta) have them.  By the time that Elagabalus and Severus Alexander succeeded the throne, not only had times changed but anything that recalled Macrinus and his son was avoided; a governor with very different agenda evidently was chosen for Elagabalus.  Behind such notions, however, lies the yawning gap of ignorance concerning the mentalities of the new cities (especially Nicopolis, which had suffered destruction in 170) where these coins were issued and used.  Monumental inscriptions, and certainly Dio Cassius and Herodian, give us no hints that might be applied to the choices of subjects for the coins issued on the Danube frontier.
                  The coins, indeed, are themselves our primary evidence, even for the names of most of the governors, Septimius’s consular legates.  This is why the delimited career of a Praxitelean statuary subject, otherwise unknown to the coinage of the Empire, a series evidently unique, is so significant.  Whatever the attendant facts may have been, such a series is historical evidence, though wanting further evidence to help explain it.  Whether the persistent variant type of 11 corresponded to a Caracalla-Sauroktonos statue we probably shall never know; seeing the variant and its persistence is irrefutable so far as it goes.  Studying them closely, one’s sense of knowing individually each of the governors and each of the engravers (“style is the man himself”) is subjective, but it is not false.  Trying to prove a point from such study would be false.   It is only what the coins themselves show that will contribute to further studies.


------------------------------------------------------------------------
[1] Pick (1898), p. 362, no. 1288; p. 433, no. 1687, pl. 14, 34–35.

[2] This study owes a great deal to all my teachers and many of my students over a half century but most to the numismatists and collectors who not only have shared their own holdings and in some cases provided photographs but have (most onerous burden of friendship) read it in several successive drafts, helping me to make it accessible to both numismatists and art historians.  The American Numismatic Society may not guess how much an exceptionally unprepared member of the summer seminar (1958) benefited from it.  Besides Doug Smith, who first showed me that [14] is not the only Apollo Sauroktonos on a coin, P. G. Burbules taught me what to look for; both initiated me into Greek Imperials.  Curtis Clay has instructed me unstintingly, answering questions concerning not only Severan coinage but provincial administration.   Charley Rhodes has shared innumerable images and encouraged me through discussions of all kinds; Warren Esty provided the most concrete advice; Barry Murphy saw that I needed help with image preparation and provided it.  None of them is responsible for what they would not themselves have said.  I must single out Liv Yarrow at the Ashmolean Museum and Dr. Günther Demski at the Münzkabinett of the Kunsthistorisches Museum, Vienna, for exceptional help with unpublished material

[3] Not only did ancient copyists know the statuary types, they probably also had sets of useful piece molds; Chr. Landwehr, Die antiken Gipsabgüsse aus Baiae: Griechische Bronzstatuen in Abgüssen römischer Zeit (Archäologische Forschungen 14), Berlin, 1985; more briefly, an excellent booklet, idem, Griechische Meisterwerke in römischen Abgüssen: Der Fund von Baia, Frankfurt/M, 1985.  P. C. Bol, Antike Bronztechnik: Kunst und Handwerk antiker Erzbildner, Munich, 1985, esp. “Grossbronzen,” pp. 118–172.  From the Baiae casts, we now know that differences, e.g., in the thickness of parts or the angles at which they meet, resulted from the reassembly of sets of piece-molds.  On this subject, see also Carol Mattusch, Classical Bronzes, The Art and Craft of Greek and Roman Statuary, Ithaca, NY, 1996.  As in the case of etchings and engravings, the meaning of ‘original’ varies from one writer to the next.

[4] For that reason, they represent their cities on alliance coinage.

[5] Great prestige had accrued to many ancient images, not only to the Ephesian Artemis but to Didyma’s Apollo by Kanachos and Alexandria Troas’ Apollo Smintheus, for example, which all are represented as stiff as the engraver can make them and are clearly distinguished from Classical and Hellenistic adornments of their famous sanctuaries, the latter usually bronze and sometimes placed in a grove.

[6] For Pliny’s sources, Pollitt (1974). The larger part of the book is a fully annotated glossary of terms, but pp. 1–111 are basic to understanding ancient sources on the arts; idem (1990), pp. 1–9.  Earlier collections and discussions of sources have a less critical point of view.
 

[7] The Lysippic one may be the Eros of Thespiae or the Eros of Mindos (it is surely the type illustrated by Todisco (1993), pls. 265-266); Praxiteles’ Eros of Parium is actually named on a coin issued for Commodus, Lindgren and Kovacs (1985), no. 275.

[8] The best textual source for the Lykeios statue is Lucian, Anachars. 7, printed by Pick, AMNG I, 1, p. 192, note 2.  Perhaps as an unhappy afterthought (“Fig. A”), the better Louvre copy of the Apollo Lykeios was placed at the head of an article on the Apollo coins of Tarsus (Bekircan Tahberer, “Apollo Lykeios in Ancient Tarsus Numismatics,” Celator, January 2004, pp. 30–38).  The statue in Athens can tell us nothing of why or how Athens came to have a cult with this exotic name; the cult gave its name to a pleasant sanctuary with a school, endowed with the famous statue before the end of the 4th century BC.  Still less has it anything to do with the thorny questions concerning the cult of Apollo Lykeios in Asia Minor, none of which can be broached here.

[9] Overbeck KM (1887), p. 320, middle, no. 25, Gemmentafel 31 (the most relevant example).  Rizzo, pl. 62, 1–2 (4, 14), 62, 3, carnelian intaglio, and 62, 4, sardonyx intaglio, both London, British Museum, whence Picard, 1948, p. 543, fig. 225; LIMC 2, pt. 1, p. 199, 81 (Olga Palagia) adds G. Hoorster, Statuen auf Gemmen (1970), 83–91, pls. 17–19, and J. Maxmin, AAA 3, 1973, 296–298.  She also calls attention to the Athens, Benaki 23722, head, without restorations (found in Kephissia; likely from the Villa of Herodes Atticus), and the heads in Copenhagen, NCG 2330 (F. Poulsen, Ny Carlsberg Glyptotek: Ancient Sculpture, p. 75, no. 70a) and Dresden, 197, A. W. Lawrence, Greek and Roman Sculpture, 1972, pl. 47b, both restored, but not the fine torso, Athens, NAM no. 1623, perhaps because the provenience is unknown, but it is unrestored, even preserving stains (not such as result from taking molds for casting); in fact, in the Greco-Roman article on Apollo, which follows, Erika Simon cites the Athens torso as one of the few found in the ‘East’ (which does not imply farther east than Patras) and lists the nine found in or around Rome, remarking the fact that Pliny saw a marble statue, which would not have been the original, either, and neither he nor any other textual source gives even a clue to where the original may have stood.
 

[10] There are few full-size copies of the Sauroktonos whether in marble or bronze (the Villa Albani statuette is small, and the bronze, full-size, recently acquired by the Cleveland Art Museum is still undergoing technical and stylistic study; even if it fulfills the most sanguine hopes for it, it has no bearing on the study of the coins).  This fact suggests either that the original stood in a town off the main tourist routes, so that sets of molds were comparatively scarce, or that it had been taken to Rome and in unknown circumstances disappeared quite early.  Among the marble copies, the Athens torso, NAM no. 1623,  is unpolished and unretouched.
 

[11] In addition, the tree trunks of the principal copies are heavily restored and tend to look like tubular pipes, but it is plain that they differed, and the lizards differed, when the copies were made.

[12] Lacroix (1949), p. 307, pl. XXVII, 7; AMNG IV, pp. 65–66, Taf. IV, 15, 24, 31 (reversed); V, 7; Overbeck, KM Apollon, pp. 303–304, Münztafel IV, 41–42.

[13] The boy athlete, conventionally known as the ‘Narcissus’ (Boardman, Greek Sculpture.  The Classical Period, pl. 234, for one of several good copies), for instance, was used in mirror image, adding a bow, as a young Apollo (Varbanov II (Bulgarian edition), p. 170, no. 2276).  The intaglio die makes mirror images unsurprising.

[14] The much discussed intent of this phrase I take to imply that early Hellenistic writers themselves no longer glorified the best artists of their own generations in the same way as those who had worked for Alexander and their predecessors.  By Pliny’s time (and possibly earlier, for a Greek perhaps of later Hellenistic date), a segue-phrase such as ‘then Art ended’, became necessary in their way of thinking.

[15] Most of the dies for the Apollo Lykeios at Marcianopolis, from Commodus to Philip, some unknown to Pick, are now catalogued and illustrated in Hristova and Jekov (2006), where in the numbered classification Apollo is reverse subject 7 (among the more generic Apollo types, but easily distinguished by posture, with the right forearm over his head and the snake on the tree).  Some of these are in temples, reverse subject 46, still plainly identifiable.

[16] Although on many that are also similar to a Rome Bonus Eventus, the ‘twig’ is not much like either grain ears or a laurel twig, some should be a young Apollo.  Besides these, there is Pick 1796, where a good specimen plainly has a laurel twig (this is a statuary pose also used for Hermes, with a kerykeion, or for confronted figures never satisfactorily named); Pick 1735, for Macrinus, 1839, for Diadumenian (different dies, but both with a recurving bow) anticipated by Pick 1796, for Septimius Severus; Pick 1688 (pl. 14, 29) for Macrinus and a matching issue for Diadumenian, both with Apollo leaning on a large Seleucid-like tripod (see Pick’s essay under 1688, p. 434).

[17] Pick (1898), pp. 338–339.

[18] All other things being equal (i.e., that it is ancient), the bronze Sauroktonos acquired by the Cleveland Art Museum (above, note 10) would be such a statue.

[19] Bogdan Filow, JdI 24. 1909, pl. 6. The new excavations concentrated on later parts of the site not excavated in Filow’s time.  Poulter, A. G., 1995, The Roman, Late Roman and Early Byzantine city of Nicopolis ad Istrum: the British Excavations 1985–1992, and, 1999, The Pottery and the Glass. 
 

[20] For references hereafter, specific to particular issues, see the list of Sauroktonos coins at the end of the text.
 

[21] For this dating, that of a Serdica inscription that should refer to Antoninus’s 6th tribunician authority, see Pick, AMNG I, 1, p. 331, note 1, and Stein (1920), pp. 18–19.
 

[22] Lacroix (1949).  Its omission is surprising, since it is RG II, no. 25, pl. 99, 21, and he did include the non-Sauroktonos Apollonia ad Rhyndacum coins.

[23] Stein (1940),